Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Football legend Tom Brady has admitted that his career could have gone very differently if it wasn't for a ruling which went his way in 2002. philadelphia parking authority customer service phone number. if 50 guys at the bar think it's a fumble, then it's a fumble. Does the Patriots dynasty if you can call it that happen? The arm is moving forward in both cases. But..the reversal was the correct call at the time, because thats the way the rule was written then, and thats the way the rule still reads today. The Patriots were the #2 seed in the AFC playoffs, having posted an 115 winloss record in the regular season. With under a minute remaining in regulation time, Patriots' placekicker Adam Vinatieri kicked a 45-yard field goal to tie the game at 13, sending the game into overtime. The Tuck Rule states, "When [an offensive] player is holding the ball to pass it forward, any intentional forward movement of his arm starts a forward pass, even if the player loses possession of the ball as he is attempting to tuck it back toward his body.". In 2012, on the ten-year anniversary of the game, Coleman told ESPN that he did not see Brady lose the ball, and, as NFL refs were trained to do in this situation, ruled it a fumble because that call could be reviewed while an incomplete pass could not. It's time to get rid of it. 4. The rule means that a potentially key fumble could now be deemed an incomplete pass. are you still mad because Seymour loosened up your fat schnozz for the Ravens to bust it open like a pinata at a bday party?? Regardless, the most common throws by far are those short positive-yardage attempts.". umm Big Ben is that you?? The tuck rule was implemented so refs wouldnt have to define the exact moment that a QB has stopped throwing, and instead is tucking the ball. For one, do you know anything about football? Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Arm is moving forward, still in the throwing motion, they hit his arm and he let's go of the ball early and it hits the ground. Most Patriots fans will even admit they were given a gift on that play. Please check the opt-in box to acknowledge that you would like to subscribe. Now, in 1976, an old, blind ref name Ben Dreith, called a phantom roughing the passer penalty on Ray Hamilton of the Patriots in an AFC divisional against the Raiders. Brady began a passing motion, but then ceased, before tucking the ball with his left hand. - Smith runs second-fastest 40 by DL since 03, Saleh compares Carr to Stafford pre-Rams trade, Allen to be ready to roll for offseason program, How to maximize leverage of No. Fact is, the refs blew that call and then the league tried to justify it by making a made-up interpretation of the rule. A ten year mental lapse thanks Mike! Plain and simple. 3 trillion in assets under management, as of March 31, 2022, the most recently available information. The game, known as both the Snow Bowl (for that copious and unceasing precipitation) and the Tuck Rule Game (for the enduringly controversial call that ultimately swung the contest toward the. But they didnt win. Patriots should have had 1st and 10 with an extra 15 yards. And, no, he would not have lost his job after coughing the ball up. After he had begun a passing motion, Brady clearly ceased his throwing motion, pulled his right hand down below his shoulder and had touched the ball to his left hand when, coming off the strong side corner blitz, Charles Woodson knocked the ball out of Brady's hands. But after looking at replays the officials invoked the tuck rule, thus handing Brady back the ball and the chance to save the game. Game was over and every player on the Raiders sideline was celebrating the victory only to be thrown back onto the field to win a game they had already won. The rule not only changed how referees call the game, but it also altered the trajectory of TB12's 4. period. Outside of the winner of Super Bowl XXXVI, not much would have changed. There should also be some kind of rule that stops the Patriots from acquiring draft picks in one year, that turn out to be better the next. I still say he had a personal stake in a Raider victory. You obviously have watched enough sports to know that there is a such thing called a momentum swing right? "[2] ", "10 highlights from Jon Gruden's Raiders news conference, including 'Tom Brady fumbled' Reference", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Tuck_Rule_Game&oldid=1142353824, Sports competitions in Foxborough, Massachusetts, January 2002 sports events in the United States, 21st century in Foxborough, Massachusetts, All Wikipedia articles written in American English, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 1 March 2023, at 23:18. I love how people act like the Pats won against the Raiders only because of the tuck rule. Luke Straub. So what would have changed? From the tuck rule game in 2002 through to the ineligible receiver confusion in 2015, Bill Belichick's Patriots have continually forced viewers to consult the rule book. he is no longer in the act of throwing. Impossible. if i was a raiders fan my bedroom would look like finkels and my mother certainly wouldnt be giving out cookies at the door. If contact causes the ball to become loose, its a fumble. Buy Raiders Tickets. @tooz56 Oh no, wait, Steelers fans would lose out then. lets 1)reinvent the rule book in the playoffs; 2) use the reinvention to OVERTURN the call on the field; 3) reward a qb who got made a fool out of on the play, and; 4) nullify an excellent defensive play. He then got hit and fumbled. Where is the arm at that point? To me its simple to fix, the tuck is not a pass to a reciever, and to some extent its not a fumble. 1:13 pm ET. I will never understand why the media will not set this straight. If it goes against the Raiders, reverse the call on the field. It's the way it's worded. [7] The owners abolished the rule with a 291 vote at the 2013 annual meeting in Phoenix on March 20, 2013. The tuck rule resulted in a controversial finish to an AFC divisional playoff game on January 19, 2002, between the New England Patriots and the Oakland Raiders. QBs dont deserve a free pass. Tge play wasnt even important in the chefs game but changed nfl history in the raiders game. It completely cheated the Raiders out of a title run. I know who else was disappointed that the Patriots didnt beat the Raiders in 1976The Minnesota VikingsThey might have finally won a Super Bowl if they had been playing the Patriots instead of the Raiders that year. While pumping the football, Brady was hit on his right side by a blitzing Raiders cornerback Charles Woodson (Brady's teammate at Michigan). Referees initially called the play a fumble and awarded the Redskins a safety, but after instant-replay review cited the tuck rule in reversing the decision and calling it an incomplete pass. Future Hall of Fame quarterback Tom Brady admitted on Monday that the infamous play in the "Tuck Rule Game" may have been a fumble. The Tuck Rule Victoria Saeli Sports 4.9 29 Ratings; A weekly football podcast hosted by Victoria (@dirtbagqueer) and Katie (@KatesOfHeaven). The tuck rule was in place for several years before that game, it was not invented on the spot as you seem to think. According to the rule, he insists the call was made correctly and reiterated those feelings. In the end JUSTICE prevailed. The Tuck rule should have never came into play. You had your chance the next season, and the Bucs beat you by 50 touchdowns Raider Nation should have sorrow about what has happend the past 10 years to a once storied franchise then a loss 10 years ago! Bill Belichick should have to insult three teams in a season, one must be in the AFC East. [8] The only team to vote against the elimination of the tuck rule was the Pittsburgh Steelers, while the New England Patriots and Washington Redskins abstained from the vote. - Three plays later, Antowain Smith picked up eight yards for a first down at the Oakland 9 and the Patriots, now going against the wind, fought to set up the game-winning kick. So if the quarterbacks hand is technically going backwards when the ball is being tucked, and the ball comes out, it should be a fumble. St. Louis went 14-2 that season and was outscoring opponents by 14.3 points a game. The gif you link is within the spirit of the rule, the bullshit one against us was not. Only once the forward motion of the arm is completed, and the ball tucked into the quarterback's body, would a subsequent loss of possession be considered a fumble. With the tuck rule the entire motion is covered, so there is no room for the ref to screw it up as a judgement call. Doesnt that now become a fumble because the passer held onto the ball past the predetermined point of a throwing motion? During the game, one play and referee ruling makes this an iconic and one of the most controversial games in recent NFL history: The Tuck Rule play. Put an asterisk next to it. Yeah, this is the problem. And how its also ignored that the Pats lost a game that same year in large part to the tuck rule being called in favor of the Jets I believe. As a Patriots fan, I also support a rule change. But on replay, Carey said it was an incomplete pass because of the tuck rule. In the . The fact that so many Raider fans are still this upset tells me that things have evened out for that bad call in 1976. No choice but to respect the officials probably correct decision. joesixpack doesnt know what a fumble is either. I dont care if your elbow grazed the turf or a defender brushed the back of your jersey as you were falling. The 106 Oakland Raiders were the #3 seed and had beaten the Jets in an AFC wild card game, 3824. The Patriots went on to defeat the Pittsburgh Steelers, 2417, in the AFC Championship Game, and then defeated the NFC champions St. Louis Rams, 2017, in the February 2, 2002 Super Bowl XXXVI on a last-second field goal by Vinatieri. Do me a favorgoogle it and watch the replay. In March 2013, the NFL competition committee proposed that league owners eliminate the tuck rule. Geeze the moron Raider fans really come out over the tuck rule. However, in the fourth quarter, Brady led the Patriots on a 10-play, 67-yard drive, completing nine consecutive passes for 61 yards and finishing it with a 6-yard touchdown run with 7:57 left that made the score 1310. After review. Yet they did. Let's look at some more examples of Tuck Rule-type plays from last season with a prediction of how they will be called in 2013. No such rule ever existed. The refs missed that play completely. thats why we have instant replay now. The Patriots were led by a young Tom Brady, who had yet to win a Super Bowl. hahaha Ben????? The rule works; people have a hard time with it because they want to think the 2001 game was ruined by it. While the Patriots were slightly out of field-goal range, Brady dropped back to pass, with no open receivers. Backup quarterback Tom Brady then led the offense to a playoff berth. Really? That Tuck Rule loss to the Patriots may have paralyzed your franchise. Once the arm has moved forward with ball in hand, it is a pass attempt even after the arm has stopped moving forward (even voluntarily), until the time when the ball is tucked away, which means presumably not just in the QBs hand but protected by an arm. Vinny Testaverde drops back to pass and arm comes forward and he loses the ball. The hit that time came from Tony Bryant rather than Charles Woodson. For once, it was the Raiders that got Hustled. With the Patriots heading to the Black Hole to meet the Raiders on. In 1999, a new rule had been introduced, which eventually became known as the tuck rule: NFL Rule 3, Section 22, Article 2, Note 2. 2004-2023 CBS Interactive. Ryan Dunleavy. ITS US AGAINST THE WORLD The New England Patriots were hosting the then Oakland Raiders in the 2001 AFC Divisional Playoff game. [1], The tuck rule was also enforced in an NFL playoff game on January 9, 2011, between the Kansas City Chiefs and the Baltimore Ravens. But that aint what this is Einstein this is an ACCEPTED AND ESTABLISHED RULE that was PROPERLY APPLIED. - Replays showed there was no illegal contact. On Wednesday, N.F.L. The call was overturned upon review and ruled an incomplete pass, with the tuck rule cited. at Foxboro Stadium, Foxborough, Massachusetts. While they were slightly out of field goal range, Brady dropped back to pass and dropped the ball after being hit by Woodson. The Tuck Rule rules that his pass was incomplete. FYI, I dont give a crap about the Ben Dreith call. @marinofreakout, you only show your total lack of football knowledge with this statement. The season had been wild for the Patriots, who began the year 02 after veteran quarterback Drew Bledsoe suffered a sheared blood vessel in his chest[6] in the game against the New York Jets. No team was beating the Rams that year without a game plan devised by Belichick. Thirdly and finally, all you raider hacks owe every new englander a thank you! By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. This rule is fine, its only the whining fans of teams that are unable to do their jobs well enough to win that want this rule changed. Before I continue, yes, the Tuck Rule made the difference in that game, for all of you Patriot fans out there. . ", The Raiders responded to the video on Twitter, saying, "Knew it.". Oh, how things might have changed if the play was ruled a fumble and not an incomplete pass on Jan. 19, 2002. (#94 -> #33, for example). st mary's academy paducah, ky how many times has the tuck rule been called The 2,957 yards rushing was the fifth-highest total in NFL history at the time. Your explanations for years were at best inconsistent. As a Raider fan, I have a different take on the matter. The most unnatural rule in football. The entire play was right in front of Ben Dreith and yet the flag stayed in the pocket. raidernationabby the rule is correct. [9] On September 23, Patriots defensive end Anthony Pleasant apparently forced Jets quarterback Vinny Testaverde to fumble,[10] but the call was overturned upon review and ruled an incomplete pass. Some may find it surprising that many of the leagues passes target players behind the line of scrimmage. New England had no timeouts left, but with the clock stopped, Brady here had a short conversation with offensive coordinator Charlie Weis. On the field, referee Mike Carey ruled it a fumble. Yes, keep the rule until each team has experienced it at least once. With 1:50 left, Raiders cornerback Eric Allen, while lurking at the Patriots' sideline, heard Brady's talk with Weis. But then, they wont have anything to whine about for the next ten years. Jan 11, 2011 3:17 PM Repeat three to five times. Dont let the damn lawyers write the rules anymore. As a Patriots fan, I always thought it was a bad rule and wished it were changed, but I also want the refs to follow the rules rather than making stuff up to call. If they had called roughing the passer when Woodson gave Brady a forearm shiver to the side of the head like they should have the Raiders fans would have had to find something else to complain about for the last 9 years. raidernationbaby says: When [an offensive] player is holding the ball to pass it forward, any intentional forward movement of his arm starts a forward pass, even if the player loses possession of the ball as he is attempting to tuck it back toward his body. benh999 says: Pereira sucks everytime he says how a challenge will go the ref comes out and does something completely different I dont care for that guy, WELL SAID theandy59 Im age 52 and watched that game myself Then the refs had the gall to add two unsportsman penalties, putting the ball on the five yard line, when in fact the game should have been over. If we would have gotten the call the way it should have been, the Patriots would have never drove down and tied the game up, thus no overtime drive, and again no field-goal. No kidding Pereira. I question the existence of the Tuck Rule. It stated: NFL Rule 3, Section 22, Article 2, Note 2. Please check your email for a confirmation. https://ftw.usatoday.com/2017/01/nfl-tuck-rule-game-new-england-patriots-oakland-raiders-what-if, that brilliant Super Bowl game plan he devised for the Rams, his game plan for Super Bowl XXV against the Bills is actually in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, 2023 NFL Combine Winners Day 2: It's (another) bumper crop of cornerback talent, LaDainian Tomlinson's nephew going through drills at the combine is sure to make you feel old, 17 NFL greats who were terrible at the scouting combine, Where to watch the NFL Combine, live stream, TV channel, Defensive Backs, The Bears have a smart reason for playing darts and mini golf in their NFL combine interviews, A Seinfeld clip was brilliantly used to analyze John Lynch's body language for Trey Lance talk, The Red Sox found a loophole in the MLB shift ban and it stinks for Joey Gallo, The Warriors left Russell Westbrook ridiculously wide open and it worked to perfection, Survivor 44: Meet the castaways who will compete for $1 million in Fiji, Watch: Man tries feeding bison near Yellowstone; it doesnt go well, 2023 NFL Combine Winners Day 1: Blazing-fast DTs give the Bears plenty to consider, Ranking all 32 NFL teams' helmet logos, from worst to best, How bald eagles really sound (it's not like in the movies), Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. Commentary on this game did not end after the season, the "Tuck Rule Game" has been debated since, with many, possibly even Brady, calling it a fumble. Duh. While it appeared that Brady had tucked the ball back towards his body, the officials were not sure and ruled it a fumble so they could review the play. Brady then completed a seven-yard pass to Kevin Faulk before scrambling for five yards and running out of bounds to the Patriots' sideline, picking up a first down at the Oakland 42.
how many times has the tuck rule been called
